Earlier this year, a few friends and I got put together an entry for the March on Film competition. Here's the finished result:

While a man complains about the dullness of Dublin, the background Waitress meets up with some strange folk in the alley way.

This is one of those competitions where they announce a few elements that you have to include in the finished piece. Mostly to prevent you dusting off a pre-made project I suspect, but it also gives you an opportunity to be creative.

One of the elements for this competition was a candle, and it was written into a scene with the gangster in an alleyway.

I got it into my head quite early on that the character in the alleyway was odd, in a Lethal Weapon kind of way. Being last minute, I had to rush into town and start picking up the props. In a pound shop, I found a really nice fake candle, made from wax with a mechanical flickering flame.

The candle is lost now unfortunately, but it was very much like this

Then an idea struck me. What if this guy was so crazy, so nuts in fact, that he would place a fake candle on the table, and rest his hand over it. Freaking out, as if it were real. Well I had to give it a try. I also got a few real candles, just in case.

The shoot was about a week later

The close up of the gangster's face was going to be last, because it was such a strain on the actor (in fact the very generous Owen Barton did star jumps for 10 minutes to work up to it). Time was growing short as it always does. We only had time to grab a single take of the fake candle.

In the edit, I realised we had a problem

The candle didn't look fake enough, but it clearly wasn't real either. The intensity of the performance just made things even more confusing. The only conclusion you could draw was that the film makers had been careless, and used a very obvious fake candle in place of a real one.

A candle that looks too fake to be real, but not fake enough to work as a gag

The only choice was to forget about the fake candle idea, and make the one in the shot as real as possible. The first step was to find some usable footage of a candle flame:

Candle flame footage against a green screen background? You got it.

Thankfully the shot was locked off so there was no camera movement. It wasn't too hard to composite in the real candle flame.

The original shotTheres a static image masking the underlying artificial flame, and the new flame on top

The next big problem was the hand. It crossed over the flame when grasping the candle. There was nothing to cut away to in its place, and close up was too intense to stay on.

There was no easy way around it, the flame would have to be masked out frame by frame. After a few false starts, I found the Roto Brush in After Effects. It took a while to go through each frame, but it produced something usable.

Some frames work great first time..But others require a lot of manual tweaking..

The composite was rendered out and used in place of the original clip, and no one was any the wiser.

Looking back on it now, it actually worked out quite well. We would never have been able to get that shot with a real candle, and I would never have planned to do anything this complicated on such a simple short film. Half the fun of these projects is thinking your way out of all the holes you dig yourself into.

I wanted to make an 'architectural' miniature of the vessel, like the industrial models Nakatomi display in their plaza. This makes sense, it doesn't have to appear realistic or weathered, just detailed and accurate. It also lets me work at a scale thats too small for a useful studio model.

Instead of kit bashing the usual way with styrene parts, I started looking for random things from hardware stores and supermarkets. I had assembled a bunch of pieces that would go well with each other.

And here they are all laid out in raw form, including the polyurethane party poppers, which are a real pain to work with

But I discovered a big problem with this approach - consumer plastics.

A lot of consumer and hardware plastics you come across are made from polyethylene or polyurethane. The one thing these plastics have going for them, is that they are chemically unreactive. Thats great for storing bleach, but it means that its quite hard to paint them; the solvents in the paint will not seep into the surface, and the pigment just flakes off when dry. The same thing happens with glue, it just hardens and cracks off.

Primer just chips off at the slightest brush

I tried a whole bunch of glues, even the all-plastics one with the special accelerator which is supposed to soften up the plastic and glue the ungluable, it didn't work. It finally struck me when I looked at the bottle of glue itself, and realised the container it came in was the very material I was trying to bond. So, back to the drawing board.

It was also dawning on me that the particular design I had for this ship was going to require massive duplication of parts. If I wasn't smart about it, it would actually be duplication of labour. I started looking at alternatives. One idea was making masters and casting the parts, but that brought its own problems. So I started looking at 3d printing instead.

Up to this point, most of the 3d prints I'd seen used the powder sintering method. This results in a rough pourous material, definitely not what you want for a small scale miniature. But Shapeways were also offering a material they call Frosted Detail. This process uses a laser cured acrylic polymer, and is much more suitable for miniature work.

So I set about designing the parts I needed in blender. Because of the high cost of the printed parts, and the volume I would need, I was still going to need to do the 'bulk' parts another way, and just use the printed parts as greebles.

My modelling skills are very rusty, but this is the kind of thing you can just make up as you go along. I measured out the real world piece as accurately as I could, and got to it. There was a lot of back and forth, getting the mesh printable over several failed submissions. But this was the final result:

The parts were modelled 'in place' on a stand in for the real world piecesThe parts need a specific layout for print, with the right amount of separation and orientationI cant complain about the packaging from Shapeways, that huge box in the background housed these tiny pieces in all sorts of bubble wrapThe parts have been cleaned and dusted with primer

The parts have a release/support material on them, similar to wax, which must be removed. The best way to do it is with an ultrasonic cleaning bath, the kind used for jewellery cleaning. I just washed them with soapy water a few times and let them air dry.

The accuracy of the parts was impressive, they had a tight friction fit in the low grade, oddly shaped party popper.

I had also arrived at a possible solution for the polyurethane problem. It was hacky, but it worked. If I wrapped the parts in PVC electrical tape, I could glue and paint to the tape surface, and it would stick to the underlying part by tack alone. I could also use tiny pieces of tape to add detail.

Ironically, when I was typing 'hacky' in the paragraph above, it got corrected to 'tacky'The parts come together quite well, and hide the fact that its a party popper stuck to a thread spoolWith a bit of mood lighting for good measure

Putting it all together into a test fit, it was starting to take shape. The next step was working out the internal lighting, and that was going to make all of this seem like a walk in the park.

Those surface mount LEDs look mighty small..

One of the things that I'm really looking forward to doing when I make the Iapetus movie, is doing practical miniature effects for the exterior spaceship shots. One of the earliest things I designed (back when this was an animated film) was the ship..


It's intended to be a colony ship, holding about three thousand people in the five cylindrical habitats, and the engine is a long linear array of accelerators. In real life, its about 3km long.

When creating convincing miniature effects, the real trick - apart from creating a highly detailed model - is miniature photography. The key to the effect is focus. In order to make a small object seem large, all of it must be in focus at the same time. You can see this very clearly when you look at the reverse of this principle. To make a large object seem very small, you blur the foreground and background, an effect known as tilt-shifting or miniature faking. This is the look you want to avoid at all costs.

A real train made to look like a miniature, the goal of miniature photography is to do the reverse (photo by Scot Campbell)

The solution is to make the aperture on the camera as small as it will go. This reduces the light that reaches the sensor, so you need long exposures. But, long exposures mean lighting effects (like windows, engines) get over exposed, so you have to do those in separate passes. That's where motion control cameras come in. They can perform the same movement as many times as needed to capture all the elements.

For the shots I wanted though, all I need is a simple pan. As it happens, there are motorized sliders out there which will do the job. They are usually used for time-lapse photography, but the principle is the same – capturing multiple long exposure images over time. It turns out the guys who made C had the same idea, so we now know it works.

There are only a few simple shots required for the trailer

Ok so miniature photography is important, but you still need a miniature to photograph. Because the design of the ship contains a few structures duplicated many times, I can take advantage of that and only build one of each. These objects can be physically repositioned, and a pass can be photographed on the motion control slider. When you composite them all together in the correct Z order, they appear to all exist at the same time.

The same object is photographed at different positions

To see if this effect would work, I decided to build a mock-up of one of the engine modules out of paper. I also put some lights in there to test how the engines would appear on screen. After photographing each element separately, I composited them together against a background. The result proved that the effect was convincing, the objects all appear to be part of a larger whole.

A paper model was constructed for the camera testSome internal lighting was added to see how it would work when photographedThis multiple exposure shows the how the principle works

The result works pretty well, it appears as a single solid objectA view from the rear to see what the engine lighting looks like in context

So I have a way to do the large scale close up miniature shots, but for distant establishing shots of the ship, a smaller model will be needed, large miniatures don't look 'small' enough when shot from a distance. I was originally planning on just constructing this from scratch using bits and pieces, but then I discovered 3D printing over at Shapeways. I created a quick mock-up of an engine pod in Blender and printed it out.

Thrown together quickly in BlenderAnd a week later it exists in the real worldSize comparison with the larger papaer model

This is printed using the coarse grained 'strong and flexible' material, a kind of nylon. Because there is no edge smoothing, and the mesh doesn't have enough faces, the curved surfaces are stepped. The Ultra Fine material with a high resolution mesh and a good paint job would be more than adequate for a long distance shot.

And that takes us up to today. I'm continuing to build out the small scale model myself, but I'm going to get a professional model maker to work on the larger scale piece over the next year or two.

It seems like an opportunity to grow always comes when you least expect it..

A short while back I went to a screening of Francesca, playing as part of the local Jameson Dublin International Film Festival. As my girlfriend is Romanian she got the tickets and was keen to go, but couldn’t make it in the end. After a bit of humming and hawing I decided to go alone, something I generally don’t like to do.

Now as I was leaving, I looked the movie up on the film festival website (which, but the way, was not very easy). They mentioned that the director, Bobby Paunescu, would be there. As I read it, I realised I had an opportunity to speak to a real life film director, a person already far along the path I’m undertaking. Naturally, this freaked me out.

Networking is tough when you’re starting out

Why? Because its scary walking up to a complete stranger, especially one you respect, and trying not to seem foolish or inexperienced. And if you’re just some random guy off the street you know for a fact that’s exactly how you will seem. I’m not sure how I managed to overcome that feeling this time round, but I made a firm decision – come hell or high water – I was going to talk to this person. I don’t care if he’s being mobbed by the entire theatre, I’ll push my way through. Not only that, I’m also going to ask him for some contact details.

The film itself was very engaging, I wont go into it too much, there’s plenty of details and clips on the web covering it. It’s bleak, no doubt, but there is a sense of upbeat hope throughout that really reminds me of Romania itself, something the director covered in a talk after the lights came up.

I asked one or two questions, about how he got started, what advice he had for someone else starting out. I was pleasantly surprised to hear that little or no black magic was involved. Hard work, dedication and the desire to do it was the vibe I picked up. It was round about this time that the Q&A came to an end, and the theatre started emptying.

I had to make my move, if I didn’t do it now, I never would.

Man, I must have seemed VERY green, embarrassingly green..

As I was walking up, two or three men beat me to it and formed a closed set around him. They were speaking Romanian, and as I got closer I realised one of them was the Romanian Ambassador to Ireland (whom I met before, oddly enough). By now it was too late. I couldn’t pretend to be doing anything but approaching them. I was in their space and there was no turning back.

I awkwardly barged my way into the small group, shook hands with all present and just blurted out a request for contact details. I was so nervous after writing them down that I could barely put the cap back on my pen. In fact, I don’t think I could manage it and just shoved it into my pocket, hoping no one had noticed. I’m sure they all did.

What’s the message here?

I’m sure you can see it coming. There’s no particularly earth shattering revelation here, and the experience is only really relevant to me. What I would say however, is that there was a sense of reality about what I did. Once you take a step and interact with the world, thoughts and wishes start to materialise into something you can actually see, and work with. It becomes a plan, a goal you can follow. Until you take that leap, its just a thought, easily postponed, regretted, and eventually forgotten.

That’s what I’m trying to do with this blog, put myself out to as many different people as possible, receive as much feedback as possible, and start pushing myself to do all the things I don’t want to do, but I know I have to do.